Marketing Automation for the Agile Enterprise


By admin March 30th, 2012 | No Comments

To be successful, a great CMO needs to make a strategic marketing automation system decision within the first 180 days. The automation system becomes the metrics backbone for the organization and is the marketing data core for lead source definition, web site taxonomy, executive dashboards, go-to-market strategy, ROI analysis and campaign planning. In my personal experience, making the system decision within the first 90 days is a best practice since it takes up to 6 months for meaningful data to emerge yet you’ll typically start getting the “what have you done for me lately?” phone call at around the 120 day mark. At the 180 day mark you start getting the CEO wondering why he or she needs marketing at all. This is one reason the average tenure of a CMO was 22 months in 2010 and all the more reason to accelerate the marketing automation system decision and begin building a solid metrics framework immediately.

In my experience the driving force for marketing automation system adoption is primarily rooted in justification and validation. Depending on the specifics of the situation you are either justifying marketing spend and campaign effectiveness or you’re justifying the very existence of marketing. As much as we don’t want to admit it, I would say upwards of 70% of marketing automation decisions are inspired by the justification of marketing at its most fundamental level.  A second force driving marketing automation decisions is the accelerating need for operational agility. In 2012 all CMOs face the same hard truth; that the pace of innovation is outpacing the marketers ability to adapt and deliver. The inability for marketers to move fast enough, to generate enough content, to bring products and campaigns to market readily enough is the major reason for the ultra short CMO career tenures. As a marketing community interested in our own self preservation, we need to make Operational Agility one our three fundamental strategic pillars. The enabling force for agility in marketing is effective automation. It enables us to make instant adjustments and automate workflows to effectively adapt to the hundreds or thousands of customer and prospect interactions that occur every day and ultimately define our success or failure. This is why it is vital we treat the automation system as a strategic asset and not simply an analytical support tool.

The set of marketing automation system options expands monthly. Marketo, Eloqua and Aprimo are maturing brands and new market entrants such as Pardot, Hubspot and Balihoo deliver compelling offerings as well. Most of the solutions worthy of consideration are cloud-based and you pay a subscription fee on a monthly, quarterly or annual basis based on your customer data base size and user count. For a small marketing department, automation solutions range from around 25K to close to $150K, but can be more depending on the size of your customer database. On average for about 200,000 records you are probably looking at around 80K – 100K. At this price point you should be demanding onsite training and integration into your CRM system. Another useful guideline to consider is adding an additional 20% in addition to the basic quote for customization requirements that will emerge later on that you won’t have visibility of in the initial purchase cycle.

To help you choose the right solution and vendor for your organization, we’ve created an assessment worksheet and vendor scorecard. The worksheet was designed for small and medium B2B companies with a requirement for salesforce.com integration but as a foundation it should serve you well and provide guidance for your selection process. We want your feedback and suggestions on how to improve the model and we’ll source your contributions in our download section. The question of how  to properly assess vendors is an interesting exercise which ultimately boils down to each company’s vector of differentiation in terms of how they address the marketing automation problem and how it applies to the “atomic unit” of your specific problem. For example, some solutionsare well suited to email marketing, some for sophisticated B2C campaign workflows, others are strong in database management, reporting & analytics, sales performance management, and the list goes on. This is a major reason why you cannot under any circumstance approach this as an isolated marketing decision. In my experience you must ensure everyone from the CEO down across all the functions, especially sales and customer advocacy, are involved in the creation of the assessment criteria and agree on the atomic problem unit you are solving for. I have seen many colleagues unsuccessfully launch marketing automation due to lack of alignment across the company. Don’t make this mistake. As a final point, assessing and implementing marketing automation systems is not a one off exercise. To make it work in your organization you need to align all stakeholders including the vendor in ongoing cadence to ensure proper usage of the system.

We want to hear about your experiences with marketing automation systems and your own best practices for vendor selection. Send us and email to info@cmosolution.com and we’ll post it to the community for discussion.

Nolan Rosen

Principal  & Cofounder

CMO Solution, Inc.

Read more »

Solving the Marketing Planning Conundrum


By admin January 24th, 2012 | No Comments

Over the past fifteen years, first as a software marketing executive and more recently as a consultant to a wider array of businesses, it has become apparent to me that there are a few universal stumbling blocks that virtually every marketing organization struggles with. Without question, Marketing Planning is right at the top of this list. What’s worse is the challenges of effective planning are growing exponentially more difficult as social media, collaboration and mobility are placing increasingly heavy burdens on companies to deliver compelling content faster, rich product features sooner and respond to customer demands instantaneously. Moreover, the need to understand your customer segments more deeply and to engage them in a wider variety of contexts is placing a much greater requirement on planning to be flexible, accurate and agile. However, as I meet with customers on a daily basis I see a collective logic growing in the marketing community favouring less planning over better planning because, “who has the time” or “we’ll plan today and have to change tomorrow”. The reality is these arguments are not new rather they are the original ones we’ve dusted off and applied in response to a more challenging business environment. As a marketing community, we need a new approach to planning that can allow us to become more agile in our processes and systems, more accurate in how we understand our markets and customers, and move faster and with greater leverage through our channels and business partners. Here is a model we have used with great success over the past few years that I believe addresses the current business environment more effectively than conventional marketing planning approaches.

Shaping Business Acceleration (SBA) 

Shaping Business Acceleration is an integrated methodology to marketing planning that provides the transparency to align an organization, the accountability to drive performance and the flexibility to mobilize sales and leadership teams within a rapidly changing and high paced business environment. The methodology is comprised of three phases; “The Marketing Audit”, “Strategic Intent Definition”, and “Change Execution”. These three phases combine to provide a much more accurate view of your internal and external environment, your impact on the organization, your key success metrics and ultimately a well calibrated path to winning. When executed across the organization SBA delivers both visibility and agility which are almost indisputable as the prerequisites for success in the current marketing environment. The marketing audit, which is the first planning phase, considers both internal and external influences on marketing. It includes a situational and environmental audit of the strength and weakness of the current plan to establish a baseline for present and future period planning. The 360 degree audit is focused across three core areas: the team, the target market and access to the market. It is approached uniquely through both structured and  unstructured audits which provide a much richer view of the company’s true strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and success metrics. Strategic intent definition, which is the second planning phase, is a three step process that expands upon the marketing audit to precisely define what success will look like in the upcoming planning period. However rather than focus on historical performance we are forward looking in this phase. There are three steps in the strategic intent definition process: “Alignment to corporate objectives”, “Modelling Success”, and “Strategic Gap Identification” which combine to architect a clear view on how marketing will contribute to goals of the corporation and exactly what needs to be done to affect that change. Change execution is the final planning step and is a two step process for identifying areas for competency improvement in order to bridge the strategic gaps that exist across the three core pillars. For Market Agility we look for key areas of competency improvement across people, processes, and systems. For Market Accuracy we explore markets, customer segments and the partner ecosystem with the intent of identifying the key programs to bridge the gap. For Market Access we are seeking to develop the right marketing mix, routes and metrics to accelerate our core initiatives. There are two steps in the change execution process: “Define Bridge Programs and Campaigns”, and “Ownership, Implementation and Dependency mapping” which combine to deliver a precision operational framework which will guide the activities of the marketing organization and ensure the correct activities are in place to deliver against the success metrics of the department and ultimately the objectives of the company.

Collaborate with Us

As marketing professionals we all realize inherently that the fundamental baseline for an agile marketing organization lies in effective planning yet we continue to struggle each year to establish clear objectives that are aligned across the organization with a measurable operational framework to support it. The problem for us is getting worse as the pace of business is accelerating and the demands to deliver faster and more accurately are increasingly challenging to meet. Shaping Business Acceleration seeks to address this problem and presents a collaborative approach to marketing planning that when executed will maximize your organization’s agility, accuracy and acceleration in the market. Ultimately we feel the solution to marketing planning will come from effective collaboration with our community of experts. We want to hear about your experiences with planning, what works, what doesn’t work, new challenges, new solutions. Please share your expertise and experiences with us so we can help our community of marketing experts continuously improve.

Brendan Reid

Read more »

Chief Marketing Officer Solution Blog


By admin August 6th, 2010 | No Comments

The CMO blog provides a unique perspective on top of mind business to business marketing topics for marketers who are passionate about the discipline and art form of marketing. The goal of the blog is to provide education, insight and inspiration for marketing executives through anecdotes and observations from the life of a Chief Marketing Officer.

Read more »

Customer Buying Cycle is the Key to B2B Demand Generation


By admin August 5th, 2010 | No Comments

Generating demand sits at the top of the priority list for virtually every marketing organization but it sits at the top of their list of challenges as well. In almost every case where a company’s B2B demand strategy is underperforming it is primarily a result of not being architected with the customer buying cycle in mind. Speaking from my recent experiences, seven out of our last eight marketing performance audits revealed demand generation strategies that were fundamentally disconnected from the buying cycle. Obviously the buying cycle is not a new concept for marketers – IDG first described a generic IT buying cycle in the early 1990’s – Awareness, Consideration, Evaluation and Purchase. A few companies, Microsoft in particular, embrace the concept in everything they do to develop a deeper understanding of how customers make decisions and what tools and techniques succeed in driving customers through the buying cycle. The buying cycle is also taught as standard curriculum in virtually every MBA program – so why [...]

Read more »


Who We Are

CMO Solution is a new type of marketing partner that delivers strategic marketing services that combine strategy and execution to help senior executives improve the agility of their organizations, gain insight into customers and find leverage to access new markets

Subscribe to CMO Perspectives